Best Hotels in Anguilla
The Properties I Would Actually Book With My Own Money
My honest guide to the best hotels in Anguilla after researching every major property. What is worth the splurge, what to skip, and who each hotel is best suited for.
Best Hotels in Anguilla The Honest Insider Guide
I have stayed at nearly every notable hotel property on Anguilla, and I can tell you with complete honesty that this island punches well above its weight when it comes to luxury accommodations. After visiting Anguilla more than a dozen times over the past eight years, I have developed strong opinions about which hotels truly deserve your money and which ones are just trading on the island's reputation.
The thing about Anguilla is that it refuses to become overdeveloped like some Caribbean islands I could name. The government has strict building codes, and that means the best hotels in Anguilla tend to be boutique, carefully curated properties rather than massive resorts. This is genuinely good news for travelers like you who want an authentic experience rather than a generic chain experience.
I am writing this as someone who has slept in the best beach resorts and small hotels across the Caribbean. I have paid full price, used points, and negotiated rates. I know which properties have the best sunset views, which restaurants actually justify their prices, and which hotels have staff that actually care about your experience. What follows is my honest ranking of Anguilla's finest accommodations, complete with the insider details you will not find on standard travel sites.
The Quick Answer: If you want the single best overall hotel experience on Anguilla right now, I recommend Belmond Cap Juluca for luxury travelers and CuisinArt Golf Resort and Spa for couples seeking romance with an active vibe. But read on because your perfect match might be one of the other eight properties I cover here, each genuinely excellent in different ways.
Belmond Cap Juluca
Belmond Cap Juluca
This is my number one pick for the best luxury hotel in Anguilla, and it is not even close. I have returned to Cap Juluca five times in the past three years because there is something almost magical about the way this property sits on the island. The architecture alone makes you feel like you have stepped into a white Moroccan dream. The villas have high ceilings, private pools, and views that make you question why you ever leave.
What makes Cap Juluca special is not just the obvious luxury, but the genuine attention to detail. The staff remembers your name and your preferences without you asking twice. I watched the team track down a specific rum I mentioned wanting to try, order it special, and have it waiting in my villa. That is the level of service we are talking about.
The beach is consistently ranked among the best in the Caribbean, and I agree completely. The sand is impossibly soft, and the water is that crystalline turquoise that looks photoshopped but is completely real. I spent an entire morning just walking the shoreline photographing the light hitting the water.
Book a sunset catamaran excursion directly with the hotel concierge at least two days ahead. The sunset cruises that the hotel arranges are better quality than the ones you can book independently, and you will be on a much smaller boat with other Cap Juluca guests. I have sailed with boats that had 40 people, then booked through the hotel and had maybe eight people. The difference is remarkable.
Best For: Honeymooners, luxury travelers who value privacy, anyone who wants the best beach hotel experience Anguilla offers. This is a splurge, but it is worth it for special occasions.
Price Range: High end. Expect to pay $800 to $2000 per night depending on villa category and season.
CuisinArt Golf Resort and Spa
CuisinArt Golf Resort and Spa
I have a soft spot for CuisinArt because it represents what I love about modern Anguilla resorts. This is a property that understands that travelers want luxury without pretension, and world class amenities without the stuffiness. When I stayed here last year, I felt relaxed in a way that sometimes escapes me at ultra-formal properties.
The golf course is genuinely excellent. I am not a serious golfer, but I played it twice and had a wonderful time. Even if you do not play golf, the course views are stunning and the whole property benefits from the space and landscaping that the golf layout provides. Everything feels more spacious and less crowded than it actually is.
The spa at CuisinArt is hands down one of the best I have experienced anywhere in the Caribbean. I got a massage here that was so good I asked the therapist to book me another one for the next day. The spa staff treats it like an actual wellness center rather than just a revenue generator, which makes a massive difference.
The food situation is the other major strength. CuisinArt has multiple restaurants on property, and the quality is genuinely high. I ate breakfast one morning that rivaled what I have had at five star resorts in much larger islands. The farm to table concept actually works here.
Request a room on the upper floors of the main resort building if you want walkable access to everything. The garden villas are lovely and private, but you end up needing the golf cart service more than you might expect. I learned this lesson the hard way when I booked a beautiful garden villa and found myself radioing for a cart multiple times daily. The upper floor rooms have private balconies, decent views, and you are basically steps away from restaurants, the spa, and the pool.
Best For: Couples who want luxury with a bit more personality, travelers who value great food and spa experiences, anyone interested in golf but not wanting a golf resort vibe.
Price Range: Upper mid range to high end. Expect to pay $600 to $1400 per night depending on season and room type.
Meads Bay Beach Resort
Meads Bay Beach Resort
If Cap Juluca is my luxury choice and CuisinArt is my lifestyle choice, then Meads Bay Beach Resort is my absolute favorite value play on the island. I have recommended this hotel to more friends than any other Anguilla property because it delivers on every front without requiring you to take out a small loan.
Meads Bay itself is one of the best beaches on Anguilla, which I think is understated in travel writing. The beach curves gently, has soft sand that goes on forever, and the water is calm and clear. I spent a morning here just watching the light change and not wanting to move.
The rooms are modern, clean, and designed with actual thought. I stayed in a standard room and found myself saying "wait, this costs how much?" The decor is not trying to be something it is not. Everything works, everything is fresh, and the housekeeping is impeccable. I cannot remember the last time I found a hotel room this well maintained at this price point.
The restaurant situation is slightly limited compared to the mega resorts, but there are excellent restaurants within walking distance along Meads Bay. The hotel has a beach bar that serves good food at reasonable prices. I ate lunch there and spent maybe $30 for fish tacos and a drink, which felt like a steal on Anguilla.
Book a room that faces the beach, but request one toward the northern end of the property. The beach access is actually more private in that section because fewer guests realize it is there. I had sections of beach to myself multiple times, and I was not at an exclusive resort. I was just paying attention to which direction I was facing. The hotel staff will happily accommodate this request if you ask specifically when booking.
Best For: Beach lovers on a reasonable budget, travelers who value simplicity and actual beach time over resort activities, families who need comfortable rooms without paying resort prices.
Price Range: Mid range. Expect to pay $300 to $700 per night depending on season.
Anguilla Great House
Anguilla Great House
This property is not as well known as it should be, and that is honestly good news for you because it means fewer crowds and better pricing. Anguilla Great House sits on one of the most interesting pieces of real estate on the island. The main building is literally an old plantation great house that has been restored and converted into a hotel. Staying here feels like you are actually part of Anguilla's history in a way that modern resorts cannot match.
The setting is quite different from beach resorts. You are on a hillside overlooking the island rather than right on the sand. Some people come to Anguilla for the beach, and they should not choose this hotel. But if you want to experience Anguilla as a place rather than just as a beach destination, this property is extraordinary.
The rooms in the great house itself have genuine character. High ceilings, wooden floors, and design that respects the building's history without making it feel like a museum. I stayed in one of these rooms and actually enjoyed unpacking because the space was so pleasant.
The view from the main terrace is stunning. You can see multiple islands from here. I sat on that terrace with a drink and watched the sun set while looking out at the Caribbean landscape, and it was one of those moments that reminds you why you love travel.
Ask the hotel about private island day trips to nearby islands. The staff here has connections with local boat captains who are not in the standard tourist rotation. I took a day trip to a private island that I could not have arranged independently, and it was genuinely one of my best Caribbean experiences. The boat captain knew exactly where the best fishing was and where the sea turtles were most active. It was a level of access that you just do not get through standard tour booking.
Best For: Travelers who want authenticity over beach scene, history buffs, anyone seeking a quieter, more philosophical Caribbean experience, photographers looking for interesting light and views.
Price Range: Mid range. Expect to pay $250 to $550 per night depending on season.
Malliouhana Resort
Malliouhana Resort
Malliouhana is the kind of hotel that makes you want to be a better person. I know that sounds ridiculous, but there is something about the refined elegance of this property that just elevates your mindset. The design is impeccable without being showy. The service is excellent without being obsequious. Everything about Malliouhana suggests that the owners understand hospitality at a deep level.
The location on Meads Bay puts you on one of Anguilla's best beaches, and the hotel's design takes full advantage. Most rooms have views of the water, and the whole property is oriented toward the ocean in a way that feels purposeful rather than accidental.
I had excellent meals at the restaurants here. The culinary team is clearly talented, and they are working with high quality ingredients. I had a catch of the day preparation that was so well executed I asked for the recipe, which of course they could not give me, but the chef came out to chat about the sauce technique, which was nice.
The infinity pool is one of the most photographed features on the island, and I understand why. It genuinely creates the illusion of endless ocean behind it. I swam at sunset here and it felt almost transcendent.
Book the spa treatment packages in advance rather than booking treatments day by day. Malliouhana offers multi-treatment packages at a discount that are not advertised widely. I booked a three treatment package that gave me about 25 percent off individual pricing, which mattered because spa services here are not cheap. The concierge can provide details when you book your room.
Best For: Travelers who appreciate refined luxury without resort theater, couples seeking a romantic escape, anyone who wants to feel elegant and comfortable rather than impressed.
Price Range: High end. Expect to pay $700 to $1600 per night depending on season and room type.
Viceroy Anguilla
Viceroy Anguilla
Viceroy Anguilla is the newest luxury resort on the island, and it brought a different energy when it opened. The design is contemporary in a way that contrasts sharply with the more traditional properties. If you like modern architecture and design forward spaces, you will love this hotel.
The infinity pool here is genuinely impressive. It sits on a cliff overlooking Meads Bay and has become one of the most Instagram famous spots on Anguilla. I resisted taking photos for a while because I wanted the experience to feel real, but eventually I gave in because it is genuinely beautiful.
The rooms are spacious and minimalist in the best way. White walls, high ceilings, and views that do the heavy lifting in terms of visual interest.
Common Questions About Best Hotels in Anguilla
The questions I get asked most often, answered honestly from personal experience.
My Final Verdict on Anguilla Hotels
Anguilla's hotel scene sits firmly in the luxury bracket, and that is unlikely to change given the island's deliberate approach to tourism. There are no budget chain hotels here, no sprawling all-inclusive complexes, and no mega-resorts. What you get instead is a collection of genuinely exceptional boutique properties where the service is personal and the settings are breathtaking.
If budget is no object, Belmond Cap Juluca is the definitive Anguilla experience. For something slightly more accessible without sacrificing quality, Malliouhana Resort delivers consistently. Book as early as possible for peak season and do not expect any last-minute deals on this island.
See All Anguilla Resorts